Simple IRA vs. 401(k) - Which one is right for your company?
There are a lot of options available to small companies when establishing an employer sponsored retirement plan. For companies that have employees in addition to the owners of the company, the question is do they establish a 401(k) plan or a Simple IRA?The right fit for your company depends on:
compare simple ira and 401k
There are a lot of options available to small companies when establishing an employer sponsored retirement plan. For companies that have employees in addition to the owners of the company, the question is do they establish a 401(k) plan or a Simple IRA?The right fit for your company depends on:
What are the company's primary goals for establishing the plan?
How much the owner(s) plan to contribute to the plan?
How many employees does the company have?
Do you want to restrict the plan to only full time employees?
The cost of maintaining each plan?
Does the company intend to make an employer contribution to the plan?
Diversity of the investment menu
Below is a chart that contains a quick comparison of some of the main features of each type of plan:
simple ira vs 401K comparison chart
For many small companies it often makes sense to start with a Simple IRA plan and then transition to a 401K plan as the company grows or when the owner intends to start accessing the upper deferral limits offered by the 401(k) plan.
Simple IRA's are relatively easy to setup and the administrative fees to maintain these plans are typically lower in comparison to 401(k) plans. Most Simple IRA providers will only charge $10 - $30 to custody the accounts.
By comparison, 401(k) plans are ERISA covered plans which require a TPA Firm (third party administrator) to maintain the plan documents, conduct year end plan testing, and file the 5500 each year. The TPA fees vary based on the provider and the number of employees eligible to participate in the plan. A ballpark range is $1,500 - $2,500 for companies with under 50 employees.
However, the additional TPA fees associated with establishing a 401(k) plan may be justified if:
The owners intend to max out their employee deferrals
The owners are approaching retirement and need to make big contributions
The company wants to maintain flexibility with the employer contribution
The company would like to make Roth contributions, loans, or rollovers available
WARNING: Most investment providers are "one trick ponies". They will talk about 401(k) plans and not present other options because they either do not have a thorough understand of how Simple IRA plans work or they are only able to offer 401(k) plans. Before establishing a retirement plan it is important to work with a firm that presents both options, helps you to understand the difference between the two types of plans, and assist you in evaluating which plan would best meet your company's goals and objectives.
Michael Ruger
About Michael.........
Hi, I'm Michael Ruger. I'm the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.
401(k) March 15th Deadline
For all companies that sponsor a 401(k) plan, the March 15th deadline is quickly approaching. March 15th is deadline for processing corrective distributions for failed actual deferred percentage (ADP) test. Failure to meet the deadline will result in a 10% excise penalty for any refund amounts that were due to the Highly Compensated Employees
401k march 15 deadline
For all companies that sponsor a 401(k) plan, the March 15th deadline is quickly approaching. March 15th is deadline for processing corrective distributions for failed actual deferred percentage (ADP) test. Failure to meet the deadline will result in a 10% excise penalty for any refund amounts that were due to the Highly Compensated Employees (HCE).
HCE’s are defined as an employee that is 5%+ owner or $115,000+ in annual compensation. The ADP test compares what the HCE’s deferred into the 401(k) versus what the Non-Highly Compensated Employees Deferred (NHCE). If there is too large of a gap between the average of the HCE’s versus the average of the NHCE, the plan is required to refund contributions to the HCE’s until the contribution level can pass testing. The typical rule of thumb is the HCE’s cannot defer more than 2% of the average of the NHCE’s to pass testing but this amount will vary based on the actual testing results.
If you are a safe harbor plan, you do not have to worry about the March 15th deadline because safe harbor plans are automatically deemed to pass the ADP test regardless of how much the HCE’s defer into plan. This makes safe harbor plans a very effective plan design for owners that are looking to max out their 401(k) deferrals in a given plan year.
Michael Ruger
About Michael……...
Hi, I’m Michael Ruger. I’m the managing partner of Greenbush Financial Group and the creator of the nationally recognized Money Smart Board blog . I created the blog because there are a lot of events in life that require important financial decisions. The goal is to help our readers avoid big financial missteps, discover financial solutions that they were not aware of, and to optimize their financial future.
